Having fun in the margins.

For those who know: I have recently self-published something for the first time ever: a historical romantasy, Binding the Cuckoo, set in Gilded Age London.

A drawing of a Victorian woman who's escaping, butt-first, from a window

So, to nobody’s surprise, self-publishing is hard, as I have found out. Harder by far than I’d anticipated. And, even with somewhat of a track-record, the truth is nobody is exactly waiting for another indie book. Anything that happens, happens because the author tortured themselves with yet another late-night marketing tutorial marathon. 

And so the thing that must keep you going, the thing that makes all this effort fun, cannot be the hope of a sales outcome. 

The true joy of writing, even in my more seriously-serious-Sirius books, for me sits in the little vignettes, the bits of funny dialogue on the margins of a story. A cheeky one-liner. An unhinged concept that has horrified my friends, and yet I find a way to smuggle in with a bit of cheeky humour.

I am such a serious writer, of course. An auteur, with an extra ‘eur’ for good measure. When I’m asked to pose as one. 

But inside I so often feel like a kid, in my own, custom-designed playground. Where anything goes, and the slides go up, as well as down. 

And if I want to add a little cuteness, then I shall do so. 

Below I include a little extract, which I had included in my novel for no better reason than because it amused me. If it amuses you as well, well then my heart is full. 


[an extract from Binding the Cuckoo]

She almost jumped with the shock and ended up pushing the needle into her finger.

“Ouch! Stephen, you startled me!” She put the pad of her pricked finger in her mouth.

“Are you a bampire?” he asked, his pale eyes narrowing with suspicion.

“A bampire?” Her mouth hung open, as Posy’s son climbed onto the sofa next to her.

“A bampire,” he replied and rolled his eyes. “Open.” He leaned forward and put his fingers on Hare’s chin, to which she objected weakly.

The domovoy made a chortling sound from the edge of the sofa, then bolted before Stephen could turn his attentions to the very fluffy creature at Hare’s side.

“Steffen”!” Francine Winchfield burst through the door and stood like a diminutive valkyrie, her hands on her waist, all outrage. All she needed to complete the picture was a little horned helmet. “Why you do?” She gestured towards him.

“I believe Stephen was enquiring whether I’m a…” Hare glanced at him.

“A bampire.” He scoffed at his sister and went back to inspecting Hare’s mouth.

“Stephen, I would really like to know what you’re doing.”

“So would I.”

Hare’s heart leaped at the familiar voice. She looked to the door. Ernest stood behind Francine, his hands folded behind his back. But the moment she saw his face, any hope she might have held out left her. He wasn’t even looking at her, focusing his attention solely on Stephen.

“Steffen wants to check if Aunt Edwina is a bampire.” Francine turned to Ernest and spoke in the tones of a school mistress when addressing a particularly dense student.

“Indeed.” Ernest’s eyelid twitched, like he almost wanted to glance at Hare. Instead, he chose to address his niece. “Miss Walker is not your aunt, Francie.” There was tension in his voice.

Hare tightened her lips into a line. It’s not like she told the girl to call her an aunt. What did he want, for her to be mean to a child?

“Oh.” The disappointment made Francine’s mouth droop for a moment. Ernest picked up the girl and walked up to the seat opposite Hare’s.

“Stephen, why did you say Miss Edwina was the… the thing you said?” Ernest asked.

“She drank blood!” the boy pointed an accusatory finger at Hare.

“I beg your pardon?” Hare felt as if she was having an out-of-body experience.

Ernest looked equally puzzled.

“She did!” Stephen folded his arms. “She put a needle in her finger and then blood came out and then she put it in her mouth!” He grimaced and shook his head in disgust.

“Ah, I see.” Ernest nodded seriously. “Excellent powers of deduction there, Stephen.”

“Are not!” Francine stuck out her tongue at her brother.

“So what is the next step in your investigation?” Ernest placated Francine with a pat on the head and leaned forward. He was enjoying this.

“I will check her mouth.” Stephen nodded sagely. He’d reddened with pleasure at his uncle’s praise. “You always have to check the mouth of a bampire.”

[end of the extract]

First 5 Chapters free for all subscribers.

Butter and (Un)healthy relationships in fiction

I have just finished the absolutely transformative Butter by Asako Yuzuki, which gives such nuanced thoughts about women, their perception of themselves, and how their bodies are scrutinised in public. In the context of my own writing, it made me think of what we consider a happy relationship in fiction, especially in romance. While some level of objectification feels necessary (after all, romantic partners generally have to find each other attractive), in a lot of romance and romantasy novels I read lately, a lot of emphasis is put on the size disparity between the protagonists. The female characters are usually tiny, to a point of fetishism (with the notable exception of some Sarah McLean novels), with their partners being almost grotesquely larger. 

The male romantic lead so often is portrayed as a bit dangerous, usually uncommunicative, with a very distinct strength/power disparity between himself and the female protagonist. 

I wonder just how much of those differences come from the reader’s desire to relinquish control in a safe setting, and how much comes from our society’s fetishisation of toxic/controlling relationships. I personally tend to feel a bit uneasy with such scenarios, especially when such relationships are idealised in romances. 

Whilst I’m not here to judge anyone’s preferences in reading, it is important to me to create a space in fiction for healthy, communicative and equitable relationships, and writing passion that comes from true connection, rather than the thrill of danger. And, most importantly, I want my readers to feel happy once they’re finished reading Binding the Cuckoo. I want them to feel confident that the protagonist is, in fact, quite, quite safe with her chosen partner. 

I want my Happily Ever Afters to have no caveats to them. I like to write my romance romantic, and my horror horroresque. And I tend to leave the two distinct from each other.

New Book Announcement!

There’s some exciting news, which I’ve been sitting on for a while. I have decided to dip my toes in self-publishing, emboldened perhaps by the experience of producing the anthology.

Binding the Cuckoo is an alternative-history, Gilded Age romance, inspired partially by the women’s suffrage movement and the domestic workers’ rights’ movements. 

It’s the first volume in the “Daughters of Defiance” series, each volume telling a story of a different couple within the same social circle.

Like many fantasy readers, I’ve seen the rise of the “romantasy” genre, but as a romance reader as well, I thought there is space for a genre-mash that focuses on the romance more, rather than keeping it in the background. (I think there are a lot of Outlander fans out there that would agree with me on this). 

And so this is a historical romance. Unapologetically, deliciously so. With a hint of magic and folklore, of course, because well… I’m still me. 

ABOUT THE BOOK:

In the late 19th century, a scientific marvel allows scientists to open rifts into the realms of myth. Powerful creatures, weakened and stripped of their memories, are brought to serve the whims of the wealthy elite…

In 1899 New York, Hare, a young woman with a mythical secret, finds herself trapped into servitude to the wealthy elite. When an equally desperate schoolmistress, Miss Anne Bonningham offers Hare a chance at freedom, they embark on a daring plan. Disguised as “Miss Edwina Walker,” Hare navigates the treacherous waters of London high society, solely focused on securing a marriage and escaping her past.

However, amidst the glittering balls and intricate social games, Hare finds herself drawn to Ernest, a charming solicitor torn between duty to his friend and his undeniable attraction to her. As hidden agendas surface and a vengeful figure from her past threatens to expose her true identity, Hare must make a choice: embrace a life of comfort and security or choose freedom and a love that could shatter the very foundation of her world.

Binding the Cuckoo is a story of love, deception, and the fight for self-determination in a world where appearances can be deceiving, and the line between freedom and captivity is blurred.

Binding the Cuckoo is coming out on the 15th of October, and is now available for preorder. Look below for the virtual book tour dates!

Some stock of WHISPERS IN THE EARTH still available!

Our successful kickstarter campaign last year has allowed us to create two beautiful editions of our folklore anthology: a paperback and an exclusive hardcover.

Now that all the backers have received their copies, we can distribute the remaining stock via The Broken Binding. But please note, the stock is very limited, so consider purchasing soon, to avoid disappointment.

Each of the twenty stories is illustrated with a hand-carved linocut print. No AI in sight. Slow art, one could say!

Again, thank you so much to all who believed in this project and helped me to bring it to life.

Click here to see the listing.

KICKSTARTER NOW LIVE!

Whispers in the Earth is now available via the kickstarter!

A fully illustrated anthology of twenty stories inspired by world folklore! 

You can pledge your support here: 

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/gabrielahouston/whispers-in-the-earth

Stories from around the world, twenty full linocut illustrations and a variety of finishes and tiers available for every budget!

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/gabrielahouston/whispers-in-the-earth

WHISPERS IN THE EARTH – an illustrated anthology

Those who follow me on social media might have seen me post cryptic reels of carving, inking and printing linocut illustrations. I have actually been working on a collaborative project with 19 talented authors.

Whispers in the Earth is an anthology of short stories inspired by world folklore, and how stories travel and grow over time. Each story illustrated by myself with a linocut print, and with smaller illustrations throughout, we offer different formats, from ebook to a super deluxe hardback collectible.

On the 21st of May, in a partnership with The Broken Binding bookshop, we are launching the Kickstarter campaign to raise money for this project.

Putting this book together is a dream come true for me. I love illustrated books, yet that’s exactly the kind of project that would be considered far too expensive and risky by most publishers. Kickstarter offers the opportunity to bring exactly this kind of an unusual project to life, by bringing artists and backers together.

If you want to hear more, you can sign up on the landing page 

http://pro.theknowledge.io/whispers

A NEW YOUTUBE SHOW AND PODCAST!

The first episode is now live, and I can tell you all the news I’ve been sitting on for a month and a bit while I’ve been secretly (not so secretly) recording the first few episodes.

THE GABRIELA HOUSTON PROJECT, is what I grandiosely named it (because it’s my project, duh.), is a series of conversations with eminently interesting people about how storytelling fits into their lives and professions. I interview writers (because I know a few of those, and they’re a cool bunch, generally speaking), artists, musicians, fundraising specialists, researchers, public speakers etc.

My first guest is authoor Stephen Aryan. We talk about his newest trilogy inspiired by Mongolian and Persian Medieval history.

You can listen to the audio version via Spotify

 

Or watch the YouTube video below.

WRITING ADVICE: 1st or 3rd person POV

I asked on my social media what people would most like to see from me here. The answer was pretty unanimous: writing advice. So here it is. Let me know if there’s anything in particular you’d like me to cover here.

Now for today’s question: choosing the right narrative voice for the novel. 1st person or 3rd person POV?

From a reader’s perspective, there’s the personal preference, of course. But for a writer? The choice of voice is a crucial one.

In terms of your genre, in the first place, it’s worth asking what is the primary driver of the novel. In a fast-paced plot-driven story, the 3rd person narrative often makes more sense. It allows the writer to occasionally zoom in and out, getting closer to the character’s thoughts and emotions when necessary, but it also allows us to introduce the elements that the characters themselves might not notice or be aware of.

There’s a whole number of styles available within the 3rd person narrative. You can have the omniscient voice, high above the characters, or walk hand in hand with them, observing their every emotion. You can opt for a feigned neutrality, stripping away the adverbiage and the emotion, so nothing but the story is felt.

In the face of such a variety of options, why would you opt for the 1st person POV? 

There are some situations where the story won’t work without the more intimate knowledge of the character’s inner life. Where that inner life IS the story, in all the ways that count. Where the question of their perception, of their reliability and biases, creates the very heart of the book.

Those questions (and more I haven’t yet thought of) are what we should be asking ourselves when starting a story. Whose story is it and how much does their perception truly matter? How can we best bring out the feelings and atmosphere we’re aiming for?

That decision might often be instinctive, but it is not simple.

Pinocchio: A short story

Illustrated initials from a German fairytale book (1919 edition)

I wince as a splinter forms just above where my index finger nail grows. Just below the top layer of the skin so I can see it crystallise from the flesh, a little swirly current of pain.

#

She’s unhappy with me. I understand. I’m late, ten minutes late to be exact. Another five and I will feel a ragged splinter on the inside of my nostril. Five more and a creamy-coloured pine flake will appear just next to my iris. 

#

A boy who isn’t good might as well be made of wood, she will say with a smile stretching her perfectly-shaped lips, lips of deep blue, expertly covered with a scarlet lipstick. 

I used to think she was beautiful, when she first told me I was to go with her. I didn’t mind my father’s tears then because my love for her had hardened my heart. How well I remember them now.

#

I don’t think her beautiful now. I see the cruel look in her almond eyes as her thin eyebrows arch when I displease her. Which I can’t seem to avoid no matter how hard I try.

#

The sawmill job was her idea. There was no need for it. But she didn’t like the flowers I picked for her. A gift of expected spontaneity.

A job would mean I could earn money to buy her gifts worthy of all the gifts she’d bestowed on me. 

A job at the sawmill was a delicious idea, so she said. She actually licked her lips, while looking at my face, searching for the slightest sign I wished to disobey her. There was none. I’d learned to keep my face like a mask of flesh before her.

And now I’m late. The shipment arrived an hour later than it should have and though I worked fast, I could not escape with the chiming of the clock. She won’t listen to my excuses. Maybe, if I’m lucky, she will turn me into a log so I don’t have to face the work again tomorrow.

#

Trees die slowly. People don’t tend to know that. They don’t tend to think of it.  

But I can hear the fallen giants as they’re moved, chained through the yard, brothers in pain, huddled together on the huge trucks, knowing they’re dead though they have not yet the peace of it.

I smile as I sign the delivery form. I can’t hear their cries. I smile at the delivery man as well, every morning I smile and listen to him talk of the traffic and his lazy brother who is a lumberjack though he’s unsuited for “man’s work”, as the delivery guy says.

I nod like I care, resting my hand on the bark of the tree closest to me. Some little comfort, I hope. An apology maybe. Useless either way.

#

I stand by the saw as their trunks are split into long planks. Even my ear defenders can’t muffle out their warning song. The trees sing to their waiting brothers to tell them there is danger, there is death coming. There’s nothing none of them can do. I can smell their sap as it trickles down, its amber drops hardening before they even touch the floor.

Every day I do this. Every day I whittle at them, like she whittles away parts of me at night.

#

And now I’m late. 

I scale the stairs two at a time, and pause to compose myself before I knock on the door.

Come in, she says. 

I put a smile on my face.

You’re late, she says. She sounds angry but I can see the delighted twinkle in her eyes, as she looks at me from below her long eyelashes.

I’m very sorry. I tried to get here as fast as I could, I say, truthfully. My eye began to itch just as I reached the top of the staircase but I would not look in the mirror. It would please the part of her which needs no encouragement.

She leans back in her chair and smoothes out the wrinkles in her dress. A dull sensation in my knees reminds me I’m amiss. I kneel in front of her and kiss her hand. The dullness in the knees disappears, dissolving into the fleshy warmth as if it was never there.

Now, I thought we should stay in tonight, she said, clapping her hands like an over-excited toddler. I’m not fooled. But she gets creative in public, so I nod with an enthusiasm I haven’t felt in years.

We sit on the ugly orange sofa she loves and watch the TV, some kind of a true crime show she likes. I sit on the floor in front of her, trying to focus on what’s happening in case she asks me about it later. I try to ignore the feeling of her icy fingers running through my hair and gently caressing my neck.

The show is good, better than I expected. She is humming softly, a vibration coming out like a purr from the back of her throat. A soft rustling. Must be her wings, I think, her large, ugly wings fluttering in the draught.

There is no draught. Something falls around my lap as softly as snowflakes. At first I can’t tell what it is. Violet and brown, tinged with red. 

Bark. Plane-tree bark. She’s been peeling the long thin translucent strips of it from my neck. I jump up and instinctively draw my hand to my neck. It feels dead, smooth. Wet. Sticky. 

I look at my sap-covered hand.

She just laughs, a deep belly laughter which shakes her whole frame. 

For today, she says picking up a small piece of bark. For wanting to run away.

I didn’t… I start. There’s no point. Because I did. It was all I wanted to do all day. What I wanted every day.

She takes my silence as an affront just as she would my words. Suddenly annoyed, she purses her lips and snaps her fingers.

Warmth spreads through my neck, and I open my mouth, suddenly breathless as the pain hits me. I look at my red hands, and feel a trickle of blood pour down my once-more fleshy neck, right between my shoulder-blades.

Clean it up, she says before she shuts her bedroom door.

I look at the strips of my skin for a moment. Then I walk to the bathroom and rummage through the mirrored cabinet above the sink. I have all the supplies ready. I spray the disinfectant on the open wound of my neck. The smell of it turns my stomach and I throw up into the toilet bowl. I kneel and lean against the wall. I just want to hide, to sleep. But my neck is still bleeding where she peeled the skin off. With shaking hands I place a clean sheet of gauze over the spot.

 I pull out the sofa bed and try to find a comfortable position. I’m bone tired, and soul tired and tired in all the ways in between. But I don’t find it easy to fall asleep. I want to think she’s spent her energies for the night. That she won’t crawl out of her room as I sleep and touch my chest with her icy fingers, turning my lungs to timber so I wake up with a start, feeling my flesh claw for the oxygen I can’t draw. 

A little boy who isn’t good, might as well be made of wood. 

***

The next morning I’m at the sawmill as usual. Where else would I be. I make use of the free coffee they serve from the large kettle. It tastes awful and does nothing to  mask the smell of the wood chippings and the sap. The best part of the job that smell, Jack, a young guy with a goatee and an already spreading gut says as he breathes in deep, like we’re at the beach. 

I mumble into my paper cup. 

Hi Nocchio.

I turn around. Molly, the accountant, comes to the mill once every couple of weeks to help sort out the wages. She is tall and heavy-set and nothing like the one I live with. That in itself makes me like her. 

Hi Moll, Jack fills the silence between us. 

But she doesn’t look at him. She smiles at me, a little shy smile which forces her eyes down even as the corners of her narrow mouth go up. Anyway, I better get going, she addresses her feet and rushes past me.

I look after her. She smells nice. Sort of sweet, like icing on a donut. 

Looks like Big Moll has a thing for the handsome Italian lad! Jack smacks me hard on my back, sending a sharp tendril of pain up my neck. I turn to him, angry. His eyes are wide with surprise at my expression.

Hey, man, I don’t mean nothing by it. She’s a nice enough girl. Just, you know, I assume not your type.

And what’s my type, I say, already turning away from him. A large pine, shorn of its branches, lets out a piercing scream as it’s cut in two. It will make a very fine MDF board. Oh no, I check the sheet. This one goes straight to Ikea. 

#

At lunchbreak I go to the cafeteria. My neck throbs under my turtleneck and I sweat. I buy a baked potato with cheese on top. The cheapest thing on the menu. 

I sit down at the only unoccupied table. The guys I work with are friendly and I don’t want friends. 

My last friend is a novelty hat and umbrella stand in our hallway. 

So I just sit quietly. 

Some of the guys thought it was because my English was no good. But that made them try an teach me. 

I kept silent, and eventually they stopped. 

May I join you?

I look up but Molly is already seating herself opposite me, shuffling around till she’s pushed the bench a few inches further from the table. She has a full plate of roast and potatoes and overcooked vegetables. 

Is this all you’re eating? She points at my plate. 

I shrug.

She looks at her plate, all self-conscious all of a sudden.  I feel a sudden pang of pity.

I already had a sandwich. Got hungry early, I lie. I rub my nose out of habit. 

Ah. She brightens up. So how are you fitting in here? You always seem to sit alone? So which part of Italy are you from? I’ve been to Venice last year, a sort of a last hurrah with my uni friends before starting work. She giggles and shuffles a bit in her seat, the prepared conversation starters tumbling from her. 

I should tell her I dont’ want the company. That’s what the fairy would like me to say. I smile instead. Venice is very beautiful, isn’t it, I say, though I have never been. Doesn’t matter. I’ve seen the postcards. Houses on water. I get it.

She seems relieved I joined the conversation. She has a snag tooth on the left of her upper jaw. I like the asymmetry of it. 

I let Molly talk as she tells me about her upbringing, her Irish parents and her childhood by the sea. She went to uni because she felt she was supposed to and emerged with a degree she didn’t know what to do with. The accounting courses got her this job, which she likes, surprisingly. 

I’m interested, in spite of my better judgement. Her life feels so normal and so safe. Being around her feels like settling down inside a warm duvet. 

She asks me out for a drink that night, which brings me back to reality. 

I can’t make it, I have an sick relative I take care of. No, I can’t make tomorrow either. Or any other day. Yes, the welfare carers don’t have the resources to support working people like us. Yes, the cost of private care is prohibitive. Yes, it’s a shame. Yes, yes, yes. 

I let her fill in the blanks in the information I provide about myself. 

She looks dispirited, but cheers up almost immediately. We have the lunchbreaks at least.

Yes, we do.

#

The next few weeks are a comfort I don’t date trust. Every day, I watch out for Molly in the morning as I walk into the milll yard. I smile back at her and wave and think of nothing else till it’s time for lunch. 

At home I take care to not show a change. If the fairy thought the sawmill was no longer a torture she’d make me find another job instead. If she suspected I spoke to people at work she would turn my tongue to wood. If she thought I wanted to run off, she’d root my feet to the ground, and turn my heart to sawdust.

#

I can’t tell Molly the truth. The truth is ridiculous. The truth is wholly, entirely unbelievable. The lies are easy. The lies are comfortable. The lies no longer have a consequence. 

#

We skip the work one day. Call in sick. I’m never sick. Nobody bats an eyelid. 

We meet at the corner of the part of town I hadn’t visited before. The dilapidated shopfronts and boarded-up deli are not exactly romantic, but the rush of the temporary escape is. The sky is grey and it smells like it’s going to rain. 

I don’t mind. I like the rain. Molly shows up in an ill-fitting pink skirt. It smells like a new polyester purchase off some dubious online store. I like it. 

I like everything about Molly. I like how she is as imperfect as she can be with a face that was bred not carved, with a body grown not turned. 

When she closes the motel room door behind us, I smile at her.

She walks up to me and put her arms around my waist, resting her chin on my chest so she can look up at my face.

She’s chewing her lip. 

She must be nervous. 

No, not nervous, she’s smiling.

She kisses me and I let her push me onto an armchair. 

She pulls my sweater off over my head. You’re very good to me, she says.

Such a good man, Nocchio.

I open my eyes. Her lipstick is different today. Looks purple in the morning light. 

Are you a good man, Nocchio?

No, not purple. The kiss smeared a bit of it on her chin and I wipe it away with my thumb. Red, bright red. Red on blue, blue lips.

Because I’m not so sure now. Are you a good man, Nocchio? A truthful man?

I hold my breath as I look up into Molly’s cold eyes. The almond-shaped eyes. 

Little boys who are not good, might as well be made of wood.

The fairy’s hands trace patterns on my chest, which tightens in swirls like frost on a windowpane. Rosewood swirls imbedded in the flesh. The fairy likes to make my pain pretty. 

I’m frozen in the chair. 

I can feel a tear on my cheek. She catches it with her nail, and lifts it off my skin so I can see. The tear hardens into golden amber. She flicks the end into a long curved needle. She eases it through the hole in her ear, her once more small, slender ear, She moves her head this way and that, admiring herself in the reflection in my eyes. 

I move before experience can curb the emotion of the moment. I surprise her as much as myself. Once the illusion of Molly is shed the fairy’s body is once more small, brittle-boned. And my hands are strong. I grab her waist and push her off me. 

Her eyes open wide for a moment, then immediately narrow into angry slits. She spreads out her ugly insect wings, and lifts up from the floor. The room is so small she nearly touches the ceiling. 

Little boys who are not good, might as well be made of wood, Nocchio.

I’m not a boy anymore, I hear myself say. 

Stupid, stupid bravado. What can I do to her. Better fall to my knees. Beg for forgiveness. Worship her beauty and power and cruelty and hope she stops the stiffening on my joints and the itching on my legs as the skin turns to bark and already flakes away from the flesh, though the blood is still pumping through the muscle and bone, in the meat still in need of encasing.

Instead I throw myself at her. I tear the gentle film of her wing with my hooked fingers, fingers of oak as soon as they touch her.

She screams, a shrill, inhuman sound. She lunges at me, though I’m bigger, though I am stronger and heavier. She would do better staying away, reducing me to splinters with a flick of her wrist. 

I grab her neck. I squeeze, hoping to drain all life from her before she drains mine.

My back turns rigid. But my hands still hold. My chest hurts as the fibres in my lungs harden. I don’t let go. Leaves sprout from my head, the hawthorne’s brutal thorns creep under my skin. 

I don’t let go

Little boys… who are not good… might as… well… be made… of… wood… 

My vision blurs. But I can still feel her neck in my hands. My hands harden into roots still wrapped around her throat. 

#

I would smile if I could as her body slackens, once the vice of her own moulding squeezes the last breath from her. 

I’ve done good.

Life with no fear?

From the series of “random thoughts I can’t shake off”, I got to thinking about how a highly socialised animal like a human function, were their brain/body unable to feel fear. Partially the question was inspired by a short story “Shudder” by Daniel Morden’s upcoming collection “Strange Tales”.

In most of the animal kingdom, the lack of fear usually means death. A parasite infects a mouse, making it fearlessly approach the cat. The cat eats the mouse, thus providing a fine intestinal habitat for the parasite.

However, in human societies, the lack of survival instinct on this basic level would not mean automatic demise, seeing as tigers and bears seldom roam our streets anymore.

Additionally, some types of survival-based behaviours in humans are simply taught. As a child you learn, for example, that should you be mean to your friends, they will cease to BE your friends. That is unpleasant. A small child might not have a concept of ethics, but they understand the unpleasantness of being left out. So they learn to avoid behaviours that cause it. Same with pain. If you touch the fire, your hand will sting. You learn not to touch the fire. In most people, they learn to experience fear in tandem with the avoidance instincts.

So what if you simply did not experience fear? You wouldn’t know you don’t experience it, necessarily. Humans find iti hard to conceptualise experiences that are alien to them. To a person with aphantasia(where you can’t picture things in your brain), the concept of imagining and conceptualising things develops in a different ways. The brain wires out the gaps, and creates a new mode of behaviour. Yet a seeing person with aphantasia might eventually realise that others do not experience the world in the same way, because the description of the process of imagining something with your eyes closed is related to something they are ALREADY EXPERIENCING.

Not so for a person with no fear. The heart palpitations, the sweaty palms, the fight of flight response… How can that be explained to someone who does not have the same physiological response.

Another question I’m mulling over is how do we categorise fear for such a hypothetical person? Are anxiety, the “jump scare” response, dread and the tingling warning that something wicked this way cometh all one and the same? What about the fight or flight response? Are fear and aggression linked?

Now for the benefits. It’s easy to conceptualise the negative result of experiencing no fear. Would you jump out at the last moment out of the way of a speeding car? Run from suspicious people eyeing you in a dark alley? Possibly, depending on your analytical skills and calculated risk avoidance. But something I wondered about was: would there be long-term positive consequences to the lack of fear response? Often, different pathways wiring their way in the human brain, can bring unexpected benefits. Once more, for people with aphantasia, they can often find their recovery from traumatic events and grief somewhat easier, as their brains don’t play the nasty tricks on them, replying in technocolour the most devastating experiences of their lives. So what, if any, benefits could there be to the lack of fear response?

One possible positive result that popped into my mind is the advantage that comes with risk-taking in business, and life in general (though that can just as well be a negative, as the lack of fear wouldn’t influence the person’s other talents and skill-sets. A bad gamble is the more likely result of over-confidence and underestimating the consequences). What about the joie de vivre? Without fear, would we all truly carpe the hell out of that diem? Or would we once again underestimate the threats? I somehow imagine the survivor bias would be strong in any research ever done on the subject.

So here it is: My list of questions with no answers. Sometimes I like it better this way.